From Jeff Vander Clute, Director of Information Services:
Perhaps you read Nick Branstator's letter on why Tripod is a great
philosophy graduate program. Well, it's true. As Branstator suggests, a wonderful atmosphere of discussion and
debate exists at Tripod . We participate daily in this "philosophical project," and by
challenging ourselves to walk the "tightrope between vision and
reality" we have established, in our lives and on the Web site, a
spirit of creatively doing right for ourselves and for our
community. Now, it happens that I am quite interested in the
underlying sensibility of Tripod, and it would be uncharacteristic for
me not to share a few non-thoughts on an ethos that I like to think
underlies this company, or at least underlies me, and hence (perhaps)
my contributions to the Tripod community. So here goes...
Most of us shun philosophy, even here at Tripod, all the while living
amidst conflicting ideologies whose origins we do not understand. Each
of us is complicit in propagating this world of personal and social
unrest, and it takes courage to recognize the terrifying importance of
our lives. Certainly, confronting one's existence is a difficult
endeavor, but it is, as some say, the unexamined life that is not
worth the effort. And to the extent that we examine our world and our
shared place in it, we are doing philosophy.
Alright, so I believe that we owe it to ourselves to think long and
hard about our lives. Unfortunately, a notion of Philosophy (with a
capital P) discourages many of us from healthy introspection. This
notion is based on, and compounded by, many of the treatises,
manifestos, and other Philosophical tomes, written in inaccessible
prose, that one encounters in "higher" education. Equally disturbing
to me is a suspicion that the shining stars of western civilization
who have publicly addressed life's difficult questions, and who, in
many cases, have contributed to the making of Philosophy, have
constructed enormous towers of thought in order to avoid personally
confronting their own contradictions. To my thinking, Philosophy
probably deserves its bad reputation.
But we can do better for ourselves. The problems we face follow
largely from our dogmatic beliefs about, say, what is good and what is
true; beliefs that we have inherited via our Philosophical
tradition. I venture that such prefabricated answers are training
wheels, in and of themselves they count for virtually nothing. It matters only that we continually ask these questions of
ourselves; not of some marvelous, and usually dead,
thinker.
Unfortunately, some of us expend vast amounts of energy
spinning our wheels on others' slippery conceptions of Goodness and
Truth when 1) the historical contexts in which such ideas are embedded
no longer exist and 2) the founding assumptions have long been
forgotten or taken on faith. The important points are usually buried,
and few people have the stamina to keep up with so much, er,
poppycock.
Thus, much of our Philosophical tradition may strike us as vapid, and
yet its influence on us is inescapable. Many of us can't engage in
healthy introspection, discussion, or debate. How can we without a
starting point that is concrete enough to be meaningful? So,
frighteningly, many of us conclude that minorities are dangerous, that
homosexuals are morally perverse, that we are better than our
neighbors, that we are undeniably Correct, et cetera. Of course such
beliefs are absurd, but are they rare?
Happily, there is cause for optimism. We can overcome the petty
grievances that make life miserable. In fact, the seeds for banishing
our more ridiculous attitudes are at least present in many of the
Philosophical movements and in the major religions that comprise our
intellectual and spiritual heritage. And they are a great deal simpler
than the towers of thought and belief that have been raised around
them. As I see it, the important ideas are as simple as "Do unto
others as you would have them do unto you." Yes, the golden rule is a
sound bite! But it is a philosophy with teeth (and a little p), and it
is a most powerful heuristic for living a good and happy life. Is
there anything in, say, the Ten Commandments that doesn't follow from
it?
Despite the atrocities that are constantly in the news, I think these
ideas are slowly catching on. Increasingly, we are shunning the
arguments of authority that have propped up one exploitative and cruel
regime after another; arguments predicated upon a "vertical"
transcendence through race, country, and God. Moreover, I see gradual
movement toward a personal answerability, wherein we, as individuals,
are more willing to examine our world and our shared place in it. The
result is that we are opting increasingly for the "horizontal"
transcendence that occurs when we place ourselves in the shoes of
others and act accordingly. This, quite simply, is the golden rule in
action. This is a philosophy worth living!
Of course, we have a lot of work left to do.
Cheers,
Jeff, Director of
Information Services (1/24/97)